Review Appraisals

Review Database

Marine reserves: size and age do matter

Claudet, J., Claudet, J., C. M. Osenberg, L. Benedetti-Cecchi, P. Domenici, J.-A. Garcia-Charton, A. Perez-Ruzafa, F. Badalamenti, J. Bayle-Sempere, A. Brito, F. Bulleri, J.0M. Culioli, M. Dimech et al.
Ecology Letters, 11, 481-489. Year: 2008

17 Moderate
Keywords
Population Fish
Intervention Marine Protected Area
Heterogeneity MPA Size; MPA Age; Connectivity; Buffer Zone
Outcome Metrics Species Richness; Abundace
Region Temperate; Mediterranean; CE Atlantic
Criteria Score
Protocol 1 Is an a-priori protocol available? 0
Search Strategy 2.1 Does the search for literature document the use of a comprehensive range of resources? 0
2.2 Are the search strings clearly defined? 1
Including Studies 3.1 Does the review apply clearly documented inclusion criteria to all potentially relevant articles found during the search? 3
3.2 Does the review demonstrate that inclusion decisions are repeatable? 0
3.3 Are inclusion/exclusion decisions transparent? 0
Critical Appraisal 4.1 Does the review critically appraise the methods of each study? 0
4.2 Are studies objectively weighted according to methodological quality? 3
Data Extraction 5.1 Is data extraction documented, repeatable and consistent? 3
5.2 Are the extracted data reported for each study? 0
Data Extraction 6.1 Is a quantitative synthesis conducted? 3
6.2 Is heterogeneity in the impact of the intervention or exposure investigated statistically? 3
6.3 Does the review consider possible publication bias? 1

Assessment of Review

Detailed assessment sheet and explanation of score PDF

View the full review

An external link to the full review which this assessment is for.

17 Moderate
Follow Us On Twitter Connect On Linkedin Make A Donation